Slingshots Forum banner
1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hi Guys,

I wanted to know what rubber is the best, as in how thick and what shape and length is the best and why
I am really interested to see what is best, and why dose no one use square rubber any more?

Please post images of what you are useing aswell

Thanks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,147 Posts
Alot depends on what you're shooting, and why. A lot of people swear by theraband gold. I have natural gum rubber on a couple of vintage forks, theraband blue on a natural I take with me in the woods, and light chinese style tubes on a couple I target shoot in the yard...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
855 Posts
Along the lines of what Harper said, out own Tex-Shooter has said several times that there is no perfect band set or slinghot. More particularly, what sort of bands you use and to what dimensions they are made depends upon many, many factors: are you hunting or target shooting? what sort of ammo are you shooting? what's your draw length? what type of fork are you using? etc., etc. As many others will tell you, a big part of the fun of this hobby is experimentation.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,465 Posts
Hi Guys,

I wanted to know what rubber is the best, as in how thick and what shape and length is the best and why
I am really interested to see what is best, and why dose no one use square rubber any more?

Please post images of what you are useing aswell

Thanks
You're going to get a lot of responses that either boil down to "it depends" or say something definite but get contradicted in short order. That's because it does depend on many factors such as how strong you are, whether you need power for hunting, whether velocity and consistency are a trump factor, the kind of ammo your shooting, range, etc. When you get to the point where you're measuring band with a micrometer, you've reached the bleeding edge and from then on, it's all about educated compromise and optimum combination of attributes for your needs.

Most people agree that the best type of rubber is 100% latex, because it gives great elongation, great resilience on contraction and has a smooth power delivery. A smooth finish results in less abrasion and longer band life. Some people use latex doped with fillers and other modifying agents and others opt for synthetics, but most people will shoot 100% natural latex if they can. There is some voodoo about colours. Some people want no colouring agent and others believe red is the least negative, but honestly it doesn't really matter.

Square rubber works. So do rounds, tubes, bands and basically almost any cross section. However, just about everyone agrees that thinner rubber that has a high ratio of surface to insides shoot faster. So, to get more speed and energy from a band of the same draw strength, shooters have started using thinner rubber. How thin? Well 0.50mm (.002") to 0.75mm (.003") is in the ballpark for what shoots fast but holds together. You can go thinner or thicker, but this works for me. Any thinner and you'll be changing bands very frequently and any thicker and performance will drop a little, just noticeably.

Given that very thin rubber tends to tear from the edges, one solution is not to have any edges, and use a tube. Tubes are presently harder for me to obtain and very few tubes are available as thin as I'd like and none in quite the taper profile that I want, so I stick to bands. I like tubes and would shoot them otherwise. There's been a lot of debate on the forums between band groupies and tube zealots but all of them want thin walls. Only people with huge surplusses of muscle power should shoot thick tubes like you get on the typical wrist-braced slingshot, or heaven forbid harpoon gun elastic. Harpoon gun elastic is only for when you want a simple bandset to fire very heavy projectiles, like a baseball, full soda can, or basically thrust a harpoon through the water and out the other side of a big fish. It has thrust but is inefficient at generating velocity. If you want more thrust but without losing efficiency, then add more thin tubes or bands. It's not unusual to see thin tube slingshots with 6 bands per side and having 2 stacked flat bands per side is commonplace.

You also asked about how the bands should taper. Again, you first need to be aware of the speed vs wear compromise. First, the good news: tapered bands are known to be faster. Tapers smooth out the draw, and reduce the weight of the back part of the bandset that must travel the furthest. The bad news is that bands tend to tear where they stretch most and two of those places are the ends of the bands. Here the stretching is intensified and so is the friction. If you taper your bands from being fat at the forks to thin at the pouch, then the weakest part of your band coincides with the place where most bands fail. Mild tapers have little impact on either speed or longevity, but really aggressive tapers on thin bands are going to lead to a very short band life. Few people would be comfortable with a taper of over 50%. I would start with about 30% and if the bands last, try for a bit more off, and if they don't then cut them a little wider.

Let me sum it up by saying it's like deciding between a top fuel dragster and a family sedan. You can make it fast, dangerous and liable to blow up every other night, or sedate and reliable. I like to aim for the super car level, where I as an enthusiast can feel some excitement and marvel at the acceleration, but not soil my shorts at the thought of a razor thin band under high tension lying across my pulsing jugular as the pouch starts to cut through the taper.


This is what I'm shooting these days:

  • Target: Double layer, 100% latex 0.50mm (.002") flatbands. Cut from 10 inch bands (8" between the fork and the pouch) for an under the chin draw. 1" at the fork. 30% taper. Gives a light, controllable shot. 5-7g (.2oz/ 90 grains) lead ball.
  • Power: Double layer, 100% latex 0.75mm (.003") flatbands. Cut from 10 inch bands (8" between the fork and the pouch) for an under the chin draw. 1" at the fork. 30% taper. Gives a heavy but manageable shot. 9/12g (.4oz/ 160 grains) ball.
You can see some analysis on band formulas from legendary makers in my blog. It's far easier, better and more honourable to buy direct than to attempt to copy them yourself.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Thanks for the reply every one it really helpes
I am going to try 100% latex, I think I might buy a ready made slingshot with this on,
I stupidly bought power bands for my black widow last week befor this post and my
accuracy has plumited
its alot more powerfull but I cant hit a coke can from 15ft
:lol:
, to be totaly honest i didnt realise how many different types there are, and I only (like a woman buying a car) looked at the colour
I thought the red on black looked cool but will keep the bands on my Black widow I think I need alot of practice to controll them tho

like PELLETEER said experimentation is a big part of the enjoyment of the hobby I totaly agree

and big thanks to ZDP-189 amazing responce I have alot to think about now






../../user/17-pelleteer/
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,465 Posts
I have alot to think about now
Yeah, I have a tendency to confuse people with over-analysis. I approach most things like an engineering challenge. Just start with a half-way decent manageable bandset and practice. That'll get you the most benefit.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
913 Posts
Tourniquets work well when traveling overseas when you can't get seem to find good rubber otherwise. They aren't tapered, but thin and cut about an inch wide, good to go, and pretty standard everywhere in the world. They're available at medical supply stores and sometimes pharmacies. It's seemingly always better rubber than what natives use and sell with their slingshots in every country I've been to. I've seen latex and exercise band material, and both are good. Something to keep in mind if you get around.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,147 Posts
I have alot to think about now
Yeah, I have a tendency to confuse people with over-analysis. I approach most things like an engineering challenge. Just start with a half-way decent manageable bandset and practice. That'll get you the most benefit.
[/quote]

ZDP is sort of like the Einstein of slingshots, I'm waiting for the day when he figures out how to get the ball to travel so fast it hits the target before the slingshot is drawn.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
281 Posts
Hi Guys,

I wanted to know what rubber is the best, as in how thick and what shape and length is the best and why
I am really interested to see what is best, and why dose no one use square rubber any more?

Please post images of what you are useing aswell

Thanks
Your question would have received different answers when I was in High School.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,465 Posts
Different answers along the lines of Durex vs Trojan?



That's been tried too, by our own mister of the unusual, Jörg. We nicknamed it the Durex Destroyer, because it was powered by two packs of the rubbers.

I wonder what velocity could be gotten out of a super thin polyurethane rubber like Sagami Original 0.02, but frankly I can think of a better use.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
281 Posts
Different answers along the lines of Durex vs Trojan?



That's been tried too, by our own mister of the unusual, Jörg. We nicknamed it the Durex Destroyer, because it was powered by two packs of the rubbers.

I wonder what velocity could be gotten out of a super thin polyurethane rubber like Sagami Original 0.02, but frankly I can think of a better use.
Depends on the draw length.
 

·
No other shooting sport compares.
Joined
·
6,460 Posts
I like tubes and flats equally. It is hard for me to find a slingshot or a slingshot accessory I dislike.
 

·
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Joined
·
1,426 Posts
Different answers along the lines of Durex vs Trojan?



That's been tried too, by our own mister of the unusual, Jörg. We nicknamed it the Durex Destroyer, because it was powered by two packs of the rubbers.

I wonder what velocity could be gotten out of a super thin polyurethane rubber like Sagami Original 0.02, but frankly I can think of a better use.
Depends on the draw length.
[/quote]
Lol, beat me to it!
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top